Subaru Legacy GT Wagon, My Dear Check Engine Light

See the cover shot?  That’s me driving at an appropriate speed, assuming the speedometer has a possible 10% margin for error, on the freeway.  At the lower left hand corner, there is a stuck light.  It is one that most people on the road fear most, the dreaded check engine light.  What you don’t see is a blinking cruise control light and an intermittent airbag light.  Most owners would panic.  I don’t.

When I bought the car, it had the check engine light.  I’ve been a car guy my entire life and even went to automotive school just to learn about them, though, I’m not a technician.  I knew enough to feel comfortable with the check engine light to get it fixed later.  After all, it drove perfectly fine.

I’ve taken it to the shop a couple times with a reputable Subaru specialist.  After the first time, the check engine light reappeared after 50 miles.  After the second time, it appeared after 30 miles.  I’m not really all that mad.  I tend to think of automotive repair as a team effort.  I give you the best information I can give you, you do your best to diagnose and repair.

I think that’s fair.

Well, I took my car to a friend’s house today.  He too, is a Subaru owner.  Unlike me, he owns an Impreza WRX STi.  If I remember right, it’s a 2009 model.  Lucky him.

He plugged in his OBD II scanner.  It pulled the same PO171 code.  He connected his lap top to it.  We took it for a short run.  A few things we noted.

1. The MAF was reading at a high level, 3.2g/in.

2. Air/Fuel ratio was right around the ballpark under load.

3. My car was 16* in advance.  I’m pretty sure that has to do with the Techron fuel cleaner I put in it yesterday.

I had a full tank of Chevron gas and the car felt perfectly fine.

Needless to say, I am reasonably comfortable driving it on a daily basis.  I notice slightly late shifts from the transmission, but the engine overall doesn’t have as much pep. The ECU is dumping gas to get the air/fuel ratio right, at the cost of horsepower and gas mileage.

I’m okay with it.  The car still gets 20 miles per gallon on the average.

Still, it’s only a matter of time before I bring it to the same shop.  This time, I’m bringing additional information during the test drive.

I may be okay with a check engine light, but it doesn’t mean I’m that comfortable with it.  It it was running well, the light wouldn’t appear anyway.

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations